Saw this quote from Esque Studio describing their mental approach to their latest glass-blown art endeavor:
"It was also important to take such a bold step, that people would not be willing to imitate what we did."
So think about that. Be bold, so no one dare imitate you. When you're carving out your brand territory, be conscious of the competitive landscape. Could others follow you easily? Could they make the same claims? Even surpass you without much effort? If yes, then consider a path over more rugged terrain.
Of course, your trailblazing must be in lockstep with your target audience's needs and wants. After all, what good is leapfrogging the competition if you're going over customers' heads.
But just because your branding and product presentation logically follows the research, that doesn't mean you can't surprise and delight people with an imaginative and perhaps unconventional take on their needs and wants.
It's a much more savvy way to show that you 'get' them rather than merely regurgitating the demographics data - data that your competition is likely using as well.

It is a common dilemma in advertising when you are looking for that one famous person to stand up and say "Nothing is better than Brand X. I love it." Do you look for a real person that fits, but is human and can screw things up? Or do you go the route of other brands and create a fictional character whose persona is under your complete control, like the King of Burger King?
It seems that there is room for both. The whole Phelps' thing will blow over. After all, most people don't even realize he also has a DUI on his record. Not to condone such repeated stupidity of anyone, let alone one making millions as a role model to kids, but people do like their flawed heroes.
Maybe the King can take a few cues from his real-life spokesperson brethren. CPB, if you're listening, have the King go berserk on the set of his next commercial (or movie?), dropping enough F-bombs to make Christian Bale blush. Or have him get into a fight in the alley over the superiority of democracy over constitutional monarchy as a political theory. Or just release some underground photos of him cavorting with Amy Winehouse for a spell.
We like our stars flawed and flayed. And the stars surely do, too. It keeps them (and the products they endorse) relevant and part of the conversation.